Performance Comparison of NavIC and GPS for a High-Intensity Long-Duration Continuous AE Activity (HILDCAA) Event in 2017

Abstract

NavIC and GPS are satellite-based navigation systems developed by India and the United States, respectively, and are widely used for ionospheric and space weather studies. This paper presents a comparative analysis of NavIC- and GPS-derived total electron content (TEC) during a High-Intensity Long-Duration Continuous AE Activity (HILDCAA) event that occurred from 17 to 21 August 2017. The analysis covers the five days of the event, along with three days before and after, using observations from a single low-latitude station over the Indian region. NavIC performance is evaluated by comparing vertical TEC (vTEC) derived from dual-frequency pseudorange measurements with co-located GPS-derived vTEC. The results show a strong linear correspondence between the two datasets, with Pearson correlation coefficients exceeding ∼0.97 throughout the event interval. Such high correlation is physically expected, as the dominant contribution to TEC arises from the common vertical ionospheric column sampled by both systems. Nevertheless, the close agreement observed under sustained geomagnetic disturbance conditions demonstrates that NavIC is capable of consistently capturing ionospheric TEC variability during this specific HILDCAA event. © 2026 by the authors.